Book Review: Kretek Capitalism
Book review of Kretek Capitalism: Making, Marketing, and Consuming Clove Cigarettes in Indonesia, by Marina Welker (2024)


Kretek Capitalism: Making, Marketing, and Consuming Clove Cigarettes in Indonesia, by Marina Welker (2024). Oakland, CA: University of California Press.
Kretek Capitalism, by anthropologist Marina Welker, effectively analyzes the diverse forms of labor enlisted in the production and distribution of kretek (clove) cigarettes in Indonesia. Welker’s book asks how the specific economic and social arrangements of this industry shape a particularized manifestation of capitalism and enlist Indonesians to perform certain forms of labor. This ethnography specifically follows kretek cigarettes (in contrast to “white,” non-clove cigarettes), of both hand-rolled and machine-rolled varieties. It centers the work of Sampoerna, one of Indonesia’s largest producers of kretek cigarettes, acquired in 2005 by Phillip Morris International. Through over a year of ethnographic fieldwork primarily with Sampoerna’s employees and its contracted workforce, Welker follows kretek cigarettes from tobacco and clove farms to factories and retail outlets, attending closely to the specificities of work enacted at each step.
The book begins by detailing the history of clove cigarette production in Indonesia, including the import of tobacco by Dutch colonists and the invention of commercially produced clove cigarettes in the nineteenth century. Through six chapters, this book explores the farm production, factory manufacturing (hand-rolled and machine), marketing, retail selling, and consumption of kretek cigarettes, positing kretek capitalism as a unique arrangement of Indonesian labor that contributes to the accumulation of capital.
Chapter One delves into the farming processes of cloves and tobacco, highlighting the hierarchy, both explicit and implicit, in the evolving relations between tobacco-farm owners, laborers, purchasers, and representatives from Sampoerna. This chapter initially examines the geography and production processes of clove and tobacco cultivation in Indonesia, before expanding on Sampoerna’s role in the increasingly vertical, contract-farmer system. Tobacco farming and selling, previously conducted through a variety of intermediaries and brokers on a quasi-open market, has shifted dramatically toward contract farming for Sampoerna’s suppliers over the last ten years. Meanwhile, industry-sponsored NGOs employ what Welker terms “industry ventriloquism” (59), using nationalist discourses around kretek to fight tobacco-control measures on behalf of farmers, who are frequently unaware of these NGOs’ existence.
In Chapter Two, Welker explores hand-rolled kretek and its balance of masculine fantasies, gendered labor, and paternalistic care. Some of Welker’s most poignant ethnographic vignettes in this chapter stem from her month working in a hand-rolled kretek factory, describing the physicality of the work and bodily rhythms of its laborers. For instance, she describes the repetitive head movements that female workers make while completing quota-driven piece work. These movements, while representing the demands on workers’ bodies due to high quota levels, also serve as small acts of resistance on the part of workers—at odds with Sampoerna’s knowledge of efficiency derived from time-motion studies. Workers also experience health side effects from this labor, from minor pains and scrapes to permanently disfigured hands from producing thousands of cigarettes an hour. The almost exclusively female workforce serves as simultaneously an object of masculinist fantasies (in which gentle, feminine hands lovingly craft kretek cigarettes) and epitomizes a “feminine fulfilment of familial obligations” (65). Amid increased outsourcing to third-party operators and attempts by Sampoerna to take advantage of geographic labor arbitrage, jobs at hand-rolled kretek factories remain in high demand.
Chapter Three highlights both the individualization of workers as well as the intimacies produced with their machine “co-workers” in machine-rolled kretek factories. Sampoerna utilizes a mixture of regimentation and gamification to motivate workers, implementing a wide range of performance indicators, prizes, and rewards for job performance. One aspect of these practices is a focus on the “economization of safety” (111), in which on-job accidents are viewed in terms of lost profits and productivity, with associated quantifiable targets. These efforts, according to Welker, work to obscure the slower harm caused by exposure to harmful workplaces and to cigarette consumption itself.
Chapter Four moves the site of analysis from the production to the distribution of kretek cigarettes, concentrating on informal labor arrangements engineered to get the product to consumers. The focus of this chapter, Sampoerna’s brand A-Mild, has an identity associated with anti-corruption and anti-establishment themes—a non-threatening, non-actionable progressivism aimed at college-educated youth and operationalized through slapstick humor and insider language. Labor highlighted in this chapter includes “sales promotion girls” (SPGs) and musician influencers. While SPGs utilize gendered affects to entice customers and meet strict sales quotas, musicians must leverage their rebellious, anti-authoritarian personas to interface with capitalist demand creation on behalf of the brand’s U.S. corporate owner.
Chapter Five discusses the retail aspects of Sampoerna’s operations, including brand representatives’ relationships with both independent and chain convenience stores and the calculative labor of these representatives as they interact with retailers. Welker highlights retail labor as “infrastructure,” examining how this labor builds connections with consumers and makes meaning physically and relationally. Sampoerna’s field retail specialists cultivate deep and personal relationships with retailers who in turn build relationships with customers, illuminating the social connections as well as the harm networks facilitated by cigarette sale and consumption. Yet Welker also highlights a shift in retail environments, away from independent mini-marts and toward chain convenience stores, in which the very experience of shopping is transformed into one of “the self as shopper,” as opposed to one predicated on customer-shopkeeper interactions.
Chapter Six turns to the moral center of tobacco consumption and production—how is responsibility (both individual and collective) produced and reified? Cigarettes, in Indonesia, function as more than just a product bought and consumed, often serving as a small token of gratitude or appreciation, more socially acceptable than money. They also act as a social binder, particularly among men; indeed, it is difficult for male Indonesians to quit smoking when social events have specific settings for smoking as a masculine activity. Yet despite the social norms around smoking, the extra-commercial role of cigarettes, and widespread advertising, people generally attribute responsibility for smoking to the individual, allowing large cigarette companies to escape blame for the harm caused by the consumption of their products.
In analyzing the particularities of laboring arrangements in Sampoerna, Welker’s predominant insights relate to the relationship of labor to international capital accumulation and narratives of post-colonial nationhood. Kretek production, from its transnational roots, has now been appropriated as a symbol of national identity and is used to counter tobacco-control efforts by emphasizing nationhood, employment, and feminine virtue. Welker emphasizes that a focus on idealized workers and consumers invoked by “a national kretek imaginary” obscure the international character of present-day capitalist production of the product, particularly in the context of increased foreign ownership of Indonesian cigarette brands. Some of this book’s strongest sections highlight the embodied and relational aspects of labor involved in kretek cigarettes, from the aches and pains of factory workers who nonetheless cherish their coworkers and personify their tools, to the relationships of musicians with their loyal fans even as they absolve themselves for taking responsibility for their fans’ smoking decisions. Welker’s book manages to highlight and humanize the particularities of work that are intimately tied with these identities while reminding us of the capitalist structure that underlies the necessary labor and the exploitation that it entails.
Areas for further exploration could include the labor of tobacco activists/tobacco lobbyists, two groups who appear briefly but are described in minimal ethnographic detail. While these groups are discussed in the context of kretek nationalism and the moral attribution of responsibility for cigarette consumption, the quotidian aspects of their work receive minimal attention. Furthermore, even though kretek smoking in Indonesia is highly gendered, additional attention could be directed at labor (including budgetary labor) within families, as Welker (179) cites a World Bank study that found tobacco accounting for a startling 22 percent of Indonesians’ weekly household expenditures.
Overall, this book adds to the growing body of literature in the anthropology of work through its focus on the labor involved in creating and maintaining a “harm industry,” highlighting labor in the kretek industry as not simply as a relation with a product or capital but one with materiality, affect, and ties to responsibilization.
